Skip to content

Research · Particle Physics

X(2370) Glueball Candidate: What BESIII Measured

BESIII has measured X(2370) in several decay channels and established its pseudoscalar quantum numbers. A newer combined analysis gives a mass near 2.36 GeV/c². These results support the glueball investigation, while the candidate’s internal composition remains an interpretation to test.

Abstract illustration of interwoven cyan and gold field loops on a dark navy background, representing a glueball candidate.

X(2370) is a glueball candidate with measured quantum numbers and several observed decay channels. BESIII’s 2024 analysis established JPC = 0−+, and a newer combined analysis gives a mass near 2.36 GeV/c². A search for one particular kaon decay found no significant signal.

These results underpin BESIII’s argument that a pseudoscalar glueball dominates the state. The measurements establish the resonance’s properties; identifying its internal composition requires an additional interpretation. This report separates those two steps.

What BESIII has observed in X(2370)

The name X(2370) identifies a resonance first reported in a mass spectrum near 2,370 MeV/c². It does not fix its mass permanently at that number. As datasets and analyses change, the quoted resonance parameters can change too.

The experimental sequence includes four main stages:

Repeated observations in different final states strengthen the resonance identification. They do not, by themselves, reveal a pure gluonic object.

What is a glueball, and why can gluons bind?

A glueball is a hadronic state whose leading constituent description is gluonic, without a valence quark–antiquark pair. Quantum chromodynamics, or QCD, permits such states because gluons carry colour charge and interact with one another.

This differs from an ordinary meson, whose leading constituent description contains a quark and an antiquark. A hybrid meson adds an excited gluonic degree of freedom to that quark-based description. Physical states can mix when their conserved quantum numbers agree.

The Standard Model’s particle and interaction structure supplies the broader context. Our account of quark confinement explains why the low-energy strong interaction requires more than an exchange of weakly interacting particles.

Two common shortcuts should be avoided. Electrons, neutrinos and photons do not contain quarks. Photons can also scatter through quantum processes, although ordinary electromagnetism lacks the direct gluon-like self-interaction. A glueball’s distinctiveness lies in QCD’s bound-state spectrum, rather than in a general division between “matter” and “force.”

The measured mass, width and quantum numbers

BESIII’s 2024 fit to J/ψ → γKS0KS0η′ gave a mass of 2,395 ± 11(stat)+26−94(syst) MeV/c² and a total width of 188+18−17(stat)+124−33(syst) MeV.

The 2026 analysis published in Chinese Physics C combined that process with the KS0KS0π0 and π0π0η channels:

M = 2,359+13−14 MeV/c²;   Γ = 170+44−29 MeV.

These are results of different analyses, not two measurements that should be silently substituted for one another. The wider asymmetric systematic errors of the 2024 fit matter when comparing them.

The quantum numbers JPC = 0−+ mean spin zero, negative parity and positive charge-conjugation parity. This is the pseudoscalar assignment expected for the glueball discussed here. It is also available to other hadrons, so the assignment narrows the question without selecting the constituents uniquely.

How the lattice-QCD comparison should be read

At hadronic scales, QCD cannot generally be solved through a small-coupling expansion. Lattice QCD discretises spacetime and evaluates the theory numerically, providing predictions for gluonic bound states.

In Gui and colleagues’ 2019 calculation, the pseudoscalar glueball mass was 2.395(14) GeV. The calculation used the quenched approximation, which omits dynamical sea-quark effects. The parenthesised uncertainty belongs to that calculation; it does not cover every uncertainty in relating its state to an experimental resonance.

Other lattice determinations give different central values. BESIII’s 2026 discussion cites an approximate 2.3–3.0 GeV/c² range for the pseudoscalar ground state across its references. That spread is a literature comparison, rather than a combined confidence interval.

Consequently, “the measured mass equals the prediction” is too simple. The 2024 central value equals one quenched result, while the newer experimental combination is lower. Both comparisons must retain their assumptions, uncertainties and the possibility of mixing. Mass compatibility motivates the glueball hypothesis; it does not establish it.

What the missing kaon decay adds

In a July 2026 preprint, BESIII searched for X(2370) → K*(892)0K̄0 plus its charge-conjugate process, reconstructed through KS0KS0π0. No significant X(2370) signal appeared in the K*-selected sample.

The resulting 90% confidence-level upper limit is 2.7 × 10−6 on the combined production-and-reconstructed-decay branching fraction. It is not a stand-alone limit on the fraction of X(2370) particles that undergo any K*K̄ decay.

BESIII interprets the suppression as evidence for flavour-singlet behaviour, using a symmetry argument appropriate to these quantum numbers. That supplies a further test beyond mass compatibility.

Our companion analysis of what the missing decay can establish about the glueball claim explains the bound, the flavour argument and the competing interpretations.

What BESIII claims, and what remains a model comparison

BESIII’s argument combines the mass and quantum numbers with production and decay behaviour. The collaboration favours a dominant pseudoscalar-glueball contribution because it considers that explanation the most natural account of the combined properties.

This is a composition claim built from several observations. A high production rate is not a direct measurement of a glueball fraction, and similar decay channels do not guarantee identical internal structure.

Chen and colleagues’ 2026 production study explores how a small charmonium admixture could enhance radiative production. Its conclusion depends on the proposed mixing picture and on theoretical inputs. It does not turn the admixture into a directly observed percentage.

Likewise, describing the candidate as “glueball dominated” leaves a question to test: how well do alternative decay and production models account for the same observations? That comparison belongs alongside the experimental evidence.

What the X(2370) results establish

The useful result is a progressively more detailed description of a resonance: observed final states, a pseudoscalar assignment, fitted mass and width, and a constrained decay route. These are substantial inputs to hadron spectroscopy.

A complete identification also needs reliable comparisons of decay amplitudes, production rates and possible mixing. The lattice glueball spectrum provides a wider framework in which scalar, tensor and pseudoscalar candidates should be understood together.

For the interpretation debate, continue to the glueball, hybrid and missing-decay analysis. X(2370) provides evidence worth testing across that framework. Its existence and measured properties should be reported firmly; a unique internal composition requires a separate demonstration.

References

  1. BESIII Collaboration, Confirmation of the X(1835) and observation of the resonances X(2120) and X(2370) in J/psi to gamma pi+ pi− eta prime, Physical Review Letters 106, 072002 (2011) doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.072002
  2. BESIII Collaboration, Observation of the X(2370) and search for the X(2120) in J/psi to gamma K Kbar eta prime, European Physical Journal C 80, 746 (2020) doi:10.1140/epjc/s10052-020-8078-4
  3. BESIII Collaboration, Determination of spin-parity quantum numbers of X(2370) as 0−+ from J/psi to gamma KS0 KS0 eta prime, Physical Review Letters 132, 181901 (2024) doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.181901
  4. BESIII Collaboration, Observation of the X(2370) in J/psi to gamma KS0 KS0 pi0 and J/psi to gamma pi0 pi0 eta, Chinese Physics C 50, 101001 (2026). Includes the combined mass and width; journal publication doi:10.1088/1674-1137/ae8acd
  5. BESIII Collaboration, Lightest 0−+ Glueball as Dominant Constituent of X(2370), arXiv:2607.20366 (2026). Preprint; the null-search and composition argument
  6. L.-C. Gui, J.-M. Dong, Y. Chen and Y.-B. Yang, Study of the pseudoscalar glueball in J/psi radiative decays, Physical Review D 100, 054511 (2019). Quenched lattice calculation doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.100.054511
  7. C. J. Morningstar and M. J. Peardon, The glueball spectrum from an anisotropic lattice study, Physical Review D 60, 034509 (1999) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.60.034509
  8. Y. Chen, L.-C. Gui, G. Li and W. Sun, Production Rate of Glueball-like X(2370) in J/psi Radiative Decay, arXiv:2605.01757 (2026). Preprint; charmonium-mixing interpretation

What is a glueball?

A glueball is a hadronic state whose leading constituent description is gluonic, without a valence quark–antiquark pair. Physical states with the same conserved quantum numbers can mix when dynamical quarks are included.

What is X(2370)?

X(2370) is a resonance observed in several BESIII radiative J/psi decay channels. Its name reflects the approximate region in which it was first reported, rather than fixing every later fitted mass at 2,370 MeV/c².

What mass does the latest BESIII combination give?

The 2026 combined analysis gives 2,359 +13/−14 MeV/c². The 2024 partial-wave fit gave 2,395 ±11(stat) +26/−94(syst) MeV/c². These refer to different analyses and should retain their uncertainties and context.

What do the quantum numbers 0−+ mean?

They specify spin zero, negative parity and positive charge-conjugation parity. This pseudoscalar assignment is appropriate for the glueball being investigated, but it is also available to other hadrons.

Does agreement with a lattice mass prove that X(2370) is a glueball?

No. A mass comparison must retain the calculation’s approximations, the experimental uncertainties and the possibility of mixing. Decay and production information are also needed to test the composition.

Leave a response

Your email address is not published.

Newsletter

Get new Quantum Nature articles by email.

New research write-ups and explainers, sent only when there is something worth reading — no fixed schedule, no filler.

Browse recent articles

Free. Unsubscribe in one click.